Popsim Satellite Meeting — Probabilistic Modeling in Genomics

Demographic Inference Benchmarking

with GADMA and Stdpopsim

Ekaterina Noskova

8 March 2023

Demographic History

Demographic History

Demographic History

 Visualization

drawn by demes [Gower et al. 2022]

Demographic Inference

Demographic Inference

Demographic Inference

 Tools

GADMA — Global search Algorithm for Demographic Model Analysis

  • Several likelihood engines ($\partial a \partial i$, moments, momi2, momentsLD)
  • Common interface
  • Effective global optimization

GADMA's useful feature: 

New Model Specification

GADMA's useful feature: 

New Model Specification

New model in GADMA that is specified only by the number of epochs.

Flexible Dynamics

New model in GADMA has flexible dynamics of population size change.

Population dynamic can be:

  • Constant
  • Linear
  • Exponential

Stdpopsim

Stdpopsim

: Easy Data Simulation

Demographic Inference Benchmarking

Demographic Inference Benchmarking

  • Simulate datasets using stdpopsim
  • Run demographic inference using GADMA
  • Use both well-specified and misspecified models
  • Benchmark $\partial a \partial i$, moments, momi2, momentsLD

Datasets

Results

Results

We performed a series of experiments for different models and data.

Three the most interesting examples:

  • Well-specified model    
  • Misspecified model with flexible dynamics    
  • Misspecified models for momi2    

Well-specified Model

    

Well-specified Model

$\partial a \partial i$

moments

momi2

momentsLD

Ground truth: 2,200

Misspecified Model

    

Misspecified Model

 with Flexible Dynamics

moments

momentsLD

Misspecified Models for momi2

    

Misspecified Models for momi2

Without migration

With 1 pulse event

With 3 pulse events

With 7 pulse events

Conclusions

Conclusions

  • Combination of GADMA and stdpopsim is an ideal framework for the demographic inference benchmarking.
  • All tested tools perform well for well-specified models.
  • Estimations for misspecified models still provide some insights about the studied populations.

Thank you!

Slides:
ekaterina.e.noskova@gmail.com                       enoskova.me